The Outfits
Death Fairy
This is a pretty good outfit, although there are a few elements that I don't like. I don't like the hair as it looks messy to me and I'm also not a huge fan of two-tone hair. I also don't like the mask since it covers the eyes completely, although it might look good when placed behind the eyes so it looks more like an elaborate makeup look. The butterfly wings are nice, although they are a bit similar to the Fairy Army Wings, but I do prefer this one. The shirt is fine, it appears to have a butterfly-like design on it. The body suit is very pretty, and I love the spider lily design on it. The belt is fine and I do like how it creates a bit of a necklace. The skirt is cute as it matches with the spider lily and it also has a nice flow to it. The shoes are cute, although I'm getting a bit tired of the ribbon-like shoes. The sleeves are fine though we've seen flowy/transparent sleeves before. I really like the spider lily and the name Death Fairy is very fitting since Japan symbolizes the flower for death or more closely to goodbyes and moving on to the after life.
Bone Guardian
This outfit is just okay to me, and I can see it becoming one of those outfits that I'm going to have a hard time using with other clothing. I like the helmet and how it has multiple horns instead of the normal two horns. I also like the multiple pieces of bone hanging from it. The shirt it fine, but it looks a bit similar to the Skeleton Witch Top from Halloween 2016. I really like the hair, it's nice to see more poofy/curly hair. I really like the fur coat. The gloves are 'meh' to me and I can't see myself using them. I'm also not a huge fan of the shoes either since I find it incohesive looking since there is random tuffs of fur on one leg, bones only on one leg, and that odd mix of ribbon with a huge bit of bone on the kneecap only on one side. The shoes are such a hodgepodge of items, I can't see myself ever using these shoes. The staff is a nice design, but again, it's not something I can see myself really using it. The skirt is nice and I like the incorporation of the bones on it. I like the bag with the bones. I am super happy to see more tattoos, I was recently going through my closet and I noticed the huge lack of tattoos we have so I'm really happy to get some more.
Banshee
I like this outfit. I really like the hair, it's a bit plain, but I love when the hair has movement to it. I like the veil and how it has the roses with the long thorns poking from it. The mouth is good and I could see myself using it for other Halloween outfits, although I wish it didn't have that odd shadowy part underneath the mouth. The sleeves are okay, nothing special but they do have a nice flow to it. The skirt is very simple, but I like it and it also has a nice flow to it. I really like top with the very tiny beading and the continued theme of roses and sharp thorns. I really love the clawed hands gloves and it reminds me a bit of the Daemonika skin that also had clawed hands, but I prefer this one since the clawed hands aren't as long. The belt is fine. The bouquet is fine, it fits well with the theme of the roses and thorns, but it reminds me a lot of the Pure Bride Bouquet just with the roses not looking as grand and having thrones. I really love the skin, it has a stunning transparent look to it (looks way better than the Luminous Spectrale Skin) and I love the the how the bottom is hazy.
Ghost Hunter
This is my least favorite outfit. The cape and hood is boring since we have had so many different capes and they all look about the same. I feel like that there is only so much that can be done with them before they all look the same. The one part that I do like from the cape is the belt-like straps coming from it. I like the hair, we have had quite a few single braid hairstyles but none as long as this one. I really like the scythe, while I don't know how often I'll use it, I do like the ghostly electricity. I also like the ghosts all around Guardian and they fit well with the theme of a 'ghost hunter'. I like the undershirt with the rips and tears and wish it was separate because I find the shirt odd looking. The shoulder pad is so ugly, the spikes are so tall and I have no idea how I'll ever be able to incorporate them in another outfit. The gloves are 'meh', they have an armour look to it which makes it's hard to pair with outfits. The pants are fine. I like the belt and it's nice to see a sword strapped to the hip instead of in Guardian's hand. I'm not a huge fan of the shoes; they do match the gloves, but I can't see myself really using them. This outfit is just so odd with the mixture of normal clothing with armour and it just doesn't work for me.
Companions
Shawbabat
It's a very cute companion and it's an interesting concept to mix a cat-like creature with a bat. Although I have to be honest, I prefer having more creepy companions during Halloween.
Sleipnhorz
I've already commented about this companion because its the same exact companion from last year. While I'm glad we have another chance to win the companion since we were unable to last year, it does feel a little bit lazy to re-use it.
The Game
While I really like Match-3 games I'm getting really sick and tired of playing the same type of mini-game over and over again. Another reason why I hate it so much is because it means that I can only get the clothing pieces in one color and if I want to get more I have to use my maana to buy it in the shop (and I can't put it on the market if I end up regretting it). I miss when we could just explore for the clothing to try and get all the colors that we wanted. I feel like most people prefer the exploration versus the games so why fix something that isn't broken?
Exploration
Despite my indifference on not being able to get this years outfits through exploration I am glad to see a bunch of old outfits from later years since it gives people a chance to get the outfits from years they missed. The drop rate of getting clothing is great since there's so many. The drop rate for the Sleipnhorz also seems to be pretty high, but the drop rate for the bait has been very low for me.
Illustration
The illustration is gorgeous, but I hate how Guardian has to ride on Lance's back. It's good for those on his route, but I absolutely despise him. Why couldn't Guardian ride on a Sleipnhorz too? It just feels like the artist is picking favorites. Another issue that I have with the illustration is that you can barely even see Guardian in it. I would have loved to get a closer look at Guardian wearing the Ghost Hunter outfit.
Overall I would say that this is decent enough event. I think this years clothing is a bit better than last years and I'm glad we had three (four with bank) outfits unlike last years that only had two (three with bank). I do like how we are able to get the clothing from all the past years, although it is a bit difficult to get exactly what you want with how much clothing there is. The mini-game is overused and needs to go. Let's go back to the old days when it was just exploration based.